The board's server will undergo upgrade maintenance tonight, Nov 5, 2014, beginning approximately around 10 PM ET. Prepare for some possible down time during this process.
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 7:41 am Posts: 19721 Location: Cumberland, RI
Stat-gasm will come after Round 3, including a new set of Ultimate Standings. Pretty sure things will be shaken up from where they were last time.
I, too, wish the categories were a little bit easier to put together and a little more even. Even with how well the "Other" category is doing with its wins, it's at an overall disadvantage because it's got more songs than any other category (that hurts its win percentage in the end). If I could somehow normalize the number of songs in each group, I'd love to. Maybe in the next tournament, I'll track categories by era, so each category would include album cuts, b-sides, demos, Xmas singles, and "other" rolled into one. In fact, I love this idea.
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 7:41 am Posts: 19721 Location: Cumberland, RI
We said goodbye to Lightning Bolt, Backspacer, Christmas Singles, and B-Sides in this round ::pours one out:: Riot Act, Avocado, and Lost Dogs are on the verge of being eliminated in Round 4--each only has one song left! Here are the different standings for after Round 3 (Wins, Win %, Weighted Wins, Super-Weighted Wins), and after breakfast, I'll put together the Ultimate Standings!
Total Wins:
Quote:
1. Vitalogy - 21 2. No Code - 20 2. Yield - 20 3. Vs - 16 4. Binaural - 15 4. Other - 15 5. Ten - 14 6. Riot Act - 11 6. B-Sides - 11 7. Pearl Jam - 10 8. Lightning Bolt - 7 8. Lost Dogs - 7 8. Christmas Singles - 7 9. Backspacer - 6 10. Demos/Leaks - 0
Win %:
Quote:
1. Vitalogy - 21-9-0.700 2. Yield - 20-9-0.690 3. No Code - 20-10-0.667 4. Vs - 16-8-0.667 5. Ten - 14-9-0.609 6. Binaural - 15-11-0.577 7. Other - 15-16-0.484 8. Riot Act - 11-13-0.458 8. B-Sides - 11-13-0.458 9. Pearl Jam - 10-12-0.455 10. Lost Dogs - 7-11-0.389 11. Lightning Bolt - 7-12-0.368 12. Backspacer - 6-11-0.353 13. Christmas Singles - 7-21-0.250 14. Demos/Leaks - 0-15-0.000
Weighted Wins:
Quote:
1. Vitalogy - 17 2. No Code - 16.5 3. Yield - 16 4. Other - 13.5 5. Vs - 13 6. Ten - 11.5 6. Binaural - 11.5 7. Riot Act - 8 8. Pearl Jam - 7 9. B-Sides - 6.5 10. Lost Dogs - 5 11. Lightning Bolt - 4.5 12. Christmas Singles - 4 13. Backspacer - 3.5 14. Demos/Leaks - 0
Super-Weighted Wins:
Quote:
1. Vitalogy - 19.5 2. No Code - 19 3. Yield - 18 4. Other - 16.5 5. Vs - 15 6. Ten - 13 7. Binaural - 12.5 8. Riot Act - 8.5 9. Pearl Jam - 7.5 10. B-Sides - 6.5 11. Lost Dogs - 5.5 12. Lightning Bolt - 4.5 13. Christmas Singles - 4 14. Backspacer - 3.5 15. Demos/Leaks - 0
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 7:41 am Posts: 19721 Location: Cumberland, RI
I forgot to update the Ultimate Standings for after Round 3! Binaural had the biggest drop, 3 spots, from 4th to 7th. The "Other" category climbed the furthest, from 8th to 5th. Here we go!
1. Vitalogy 2. No Code 3. Yield 4. Vs 5. Other 6. Ten 7. Binaural 8. Riot Act 9. B-Sides 9. Pearl Jam 10. Lost Dogs 11. Lightning Bolt 12. Christmas Singles 13. Backspacer 14. Demos/Leaks
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 7:41 am Posts: 19721 Location: Cumberland, RI
With three songs left, it looks like Vitalogy is going to run away with this! I will certainly update everything after the final round, though. I'll also create the Overall Standings, which will rank the songs from 1-??? (however many songs there were), based on which round they were eliminated in and how they fared in their final round.
Only interesting tidbit I've got floating around today is that Sometimes is the only song in the final 8 that didn't get a first-round bye (Not For You and Off He Goes were the only other tunes that made it to the final 16 without a bye).
Joined: Thu March 21, 2013 1:08 am Posts: 2582 Location: Pennsyltucky
Simple Torture wrote:
Albums with songs in the Top 20:
Ten - 1 Vs - 2 Vitalogy - 4 No Code - 4 Yield - 1 Binaural - 2 Riot Act -1 Lost Dogs - 1 "Other" - 4
Really surprised that Yield didn't end up with a much better showing... especially considering how much it seems to be revered by RM. Also, a little surprised that No Code held up so well.
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 7:41 am Posts: 19721 Location: Cumberland, RI
More coming tomorrow, but for now, here are the songs in the tournament ranked from 1-211. How it works: songs are ranked by which round they got to and then what percentage of their match's votes in that round. So, for example: of all the songs that were eliminated in Round 3, Black had the vote percentage in that round (49.45%) so it's ranked number 1 in that round (which is good for 33rd overall). And so on. I've spoliered it since it's such a long list; enjoy!
1 Insignificance 2 Corduroy 3 Immortality 4 Tremor Christ 5 Release 6 Long Road 7 Sometimes 8 Daughter 9 Off He Goes 10 Man of the Hour 11 Go 12 In My Tree 13 Hail Hail 14 I Got Shit 15 All or None 16 Not For You 17 State of Love And Trust 18 Nothing As It Seems 19 Sad 20 Faithfull 21 Breath 22 All Those Yesterday 23 Smile 24 Do The Evolution 25 Last Exit 26 Rearviewmirror 27 Alive 28 Severed Hand 29 No Way 30 Hard to Imagine 31 Elderly Woman 32 Porch 33 Black 34 Given To Fly 35 Rival 36 Present Tense 37 Who You Are 38 Nothingman 39 Grievance 40 Brain of J 41 I Am Mine 42 Even Flow 43 Sleight of Hand 44 Cropduster 45 Breakerfall 46 Indifference 47 Rats 48 Spin the Black Circle 49 Deep 50 Whipping 51 Down 52 World Wide Suicide 53 All Night 54 Parachutes 55 Wash 56 Mind Your Manners 57 Push Me/Pull Me 58 Save You 59 Around the Bend 60 Strangest Tribe 61 Got Some 62 MFC 63 Glorified G 64 Swallowed Whole 65 Red Mosquito 66 Marker In The Sand 67 In The Moonlight 68 Yellow Ledbetter 69 Animal 70 In Hiding 71 Parting Ways 72 Dead Man 73 Love Boat Captain 74 Pendulum 75 Other Side 76 Can't Keep 77 Help Help 78 WMA 79 Light Years 80 Jeremy 81 Blood 82 Last Kiss 83 Of The Girl 84 Lightning Bolt 85 Life Wasted 86 Thumbing My Way 87 Force of Nature 88 Habit 89 Dissident 90 Army Reserve 91 Johnny Guitar 92 Undone 93 Lowlight 94 Education 95 You Are 96 Yellow Moon 97 Satan's Bed 98 The Fixer 99 Footsteps 100 Amongst The Waves 101 Pilate 102 My Father's Son 103 Oceans 104 Garden 105 Just Breathe 106 Evacuation 107 Infallible 108 Aye Davanita 109 Thin Air 110 You 111 Getaway 112 Betterman 113 Crazy Mary 114 Drifting 115 Hold On (Acoustic) 116 Comatose 117 Black Red Yellow 118 Alone 119 Sonic Reducer 120 Wishlist 121 Angel 122 Last Soldier 123 Inside Job 124 The End 125 Unthought Known 126 Of The Earth 127 Unemployable 128 Hold On 129 Leash 130 Sirens 131 Cold Confession 132 Master/Slave 133 Sleeping By Myself 134 Lukin 135 Bushleaguer 136 Come Back 137 Bugs 138 Half Full 139 Let Me Sleep 140 Sunburn 141 Ghost 142 Gone 143 NAIS (Demo) 144 Let the Records Play 145 Bee Girl 146 Gods' Dice 147 Why Go 148 Out Of My Mind 149 Leatherman 150 Pry, To 151 Supersonic 152 Soon Forget 153 Happy When I'm Crying 154 Let It Ride 155 Speed of Sound 156 Brother 157 Better Things 158 Fatal 159 4/20/02 160 Once 161 Gonna See My Friend 162 Someday At Christmas 163 Gremmie Out Of Control 164 2000 Miles Blues 165 I've Got A Feeling 166 Get Right 167 Love Reign O'er Me 168 Green Disease 169 Hummus 170 Dirty Frank 171 Untitled (Spoken) 172 Don't Gimme No Lip 173 Be Like Wind 174 Speed of Sound (Demo) 175 Puzzles and Games 176 Wasted Reprise 177 Harmony 178 I'm Open 179 Acoustic #1 180 Mankind 181 Leavin' Here 182 Golden State 183 Olympic Platinum 184 Big Wave 185 Falling Down 186 Whale Song 187 Rock Around Barack 188 Stupid Mop 189 Thunderclap 190 Need To Know 191 Just A Girl 192 Anything In Between 193 Arc 194 Ole 195 Sweet Lew 196 Chinese 197 Foldback 198 Gone (Demo) 199 Future Days 200 Santa God 201 Red Dot 202 Swet Lew (Demo) 203 Evil Little Goat 204 Devil Doll 205 Hitchhiker 206 Santa Cruz 207 It Ain't Like That 208 Jingle Bells 209 Turning Mist 210 I Just Want To Have Something To Do 211 Wishing Well 212 Don't Believe in Xmas 213 The Real Thing
Lol at the Real Thing in last place. Thanks for your hard work! This would make a pretty decent -- although not terribly surprising -- setlist.
1 Insignificance 2 Corduroy 3 Immortality 4 Tremor Christ 5 Release 6 Long Road 7 Sometimes 8 Daughter 9 Off He Goes 10 Man of the Hour 11 Go 12 In My Tree 13 Hail Hail 14 I Got Shit 15 All or None 16 Not For You 17 State of Love And Trust 18 Nothing As It Seems 19 Sad 20 Faithfull 21 Breath 22 All Those Yesterdays 23 Smile 24 Do The Evolution 25 Last Exit 26 Rearviewmirror 27 Alive 28 Severed Hand 29 No Way 30 Hard to Imagine 31 Elderly Woman 32 Porch 33 Black 34 Given To Fly
Joined: Wed February 06, 2013 2:47 am Posts: 17534 Location: Scooby Doo
Post 2000 madness (up to 100)
1 Insignificance 10 Man of the Hour 15 All or None 18 Nothing As It Seems 19 Sad 28 Severed Hand 35 Rival 39 Grievance 41 I Am Mine 43 Sleight of Hand 44 Cropduster 45 Breakerfall
51 Down 52 World Wide Suicide 54 Parachutes 56 Mind Your Manners 58 Save You 60 Strangest Tribe 61 Got Some 64 Swallowed Whole 66 Marker In The Sand 67 In The Moonlight 73 Love Boat Captain 74 Pendulum 75 Other Side 76 Can't Keep 77 Help Help 79 Light Years 83 Of The Girl 84 Lightning Bolt 85 Life Wasted 86 Thumbing My Way 87 Force of Nature 90 Army Reserve 91 Johnny Guitar 92 Undone 94 Education 95 You Are 96 Yellow Moon 98 The Fixer 100 Amongst The Waves
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 7:41 am Posts: 19721 Location: Cumberland, RI
Final Standings!
Ultimate Standings - These standings represent each album's average standing across the other 4 ranking systems. Ties (there are two of them) are broken by which album had a highest rank in any system (so, for example: Vs. and "Other" were tied for fourth, but "Other" was third in Weighted Wins and Vs. never ranked higher than fourth, so "Other" goes higher).
Quote:
1. Vitalogy 2. No Code 3. Binaural 4. Other 5. Vs 6. Yield 7. Ten 8. Riot Act 9. B-Sides 10.Pearl Jam 11. Lost Dogs 12. Lightning Bolt 13. Christmas Singles 14. Backspacer 15. Demos/Leaks
Total Wins - Simply the total number of wins across all rounds; each win counts as one point, regardless of rounds.
Quote:
1. Vitalogy - 32 2. No Code - 25 3. Yield - 20 3. Binaural - 20 4. Vs - 19 4. Other - 19 5. Ten - 16 6. Riot Act - 12 7. B-Sides - 11 8. Pearl Jam - 10 9. Lightning Bolt - 7 9. Lost Dogs - 7 9. Christmas Singles - 7 10. Backspacer - 6 11. Demos/Leaks - 0
Win Percentage - Win percentage across all rounds, using win number from "Total Wins." Ties are broken with number of wins first, then by number of losses.
Quote:
1. Vitalogy - 32-14-0.696 2. No Code - 25-15-0.625 3. Binaural - 20-12-0.625 4. Vs - 19-12-0.613 5. Yield - 20-13-0.606 6. Ten - 16-12-0.571 7. Other - 19-22-0.463 8. Riot Act - 12-14-0.462 9. B-Sides - 11-13-0.458 10. Pearl Jam - 10-13-0.435 11. Lightning Bolt - 7-12-0.368 11. Lost Dogs - 7-12-0.368 12. Backspacer - 6-11-0.353 13. Christmas Singles - 7-21-0.250 14. Demos/Leaks - 0-15-0.000
Weighted Wins - In this ranking system, Round 1 wins are only worth half a point, since there were so many blowouts in that round. A win in every other round is worth 1 point.
Quote:
1. Vitalogy - 28 2. No Code - 21.5 3. Other - 17.5 4. Binaural - 16.5 5. Vs - 16 5. Yield - 16 6. Ten - 13.5 7. Riot Act - 9 8. Pearl Jam - 7 9. B-Sides - 6.5 10. Lost Dogs - 5 11. Lightning Bolt - 4.5 12. Christmas Singles - 4 13. Backspacer - 3.5 14. Demos/Leaks - 0
Super Weighted Wins - For this system, Round 1 wins are only worth half of a point, for the same reasons above. Round 2 wins are worth 1, Round 3 wins are worth 1.5...and then every round goes up half of a point.
Quote:
1. Vitalogy - 47.5 2. No Code - 29.5 3. Binaural - 27.5 4. Other - 25 5. Vs - 21.5 6. Yield - 18 7. Ten - 17.5 8. Riot Act - 10.5 9. Pearl Jam - 7.5 10. B-Sides - 6.5 11. Lost Dogs - 5.5 12. Lightning Bolt - 4.5 13. Christmas Singles - 4 14. Backspacer - 3.5 15. Demos/Leaks - 0
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 7:41 am Posts: 19721 Location: Cumberland, RI
Highest ranking song for each album:
Ten - Release (#5) Vs - Daughter (#8) Vitalogy - Corduroy (#2) No Code - Sometimes (#7) Yield - Faithfull (#20) Binaural - Insignificance (#1) Riot Act - All Or None (#15) Pearl Jam - Severed Hand (#28) Backspacer - Got Some (#61) Lightning Bolt - Mind Your Manners (#56) B-Sides - Down (#51) Lost Dogs - Sad (#19) Christmas Singles - Strangest Tribe (#60) Demos/Leaks - Cold Confession (#131) Other - Long Road (#6)
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum