In the Moonlight vs. Animal

Another close one but Animal takes this.

The way he just belts out some of those notes. In a few years it'll reach the point where it almost starts to border on self-parody, but it's so good here.

That's a great jamily image in that video still

I'm less impressed by Animal than many around here, I think, but it's an easy vote here.

This should be a landslide win for Animal.

Animal is my hands down favorite PJ song

that was a great video, stip

As someone who stans In The Moonlight to an absurd degree, someone who desperately wants to see Moonlight in the Final Four, I can't in good conscience vote for it here.

Animal is just better.

In the Moonlight is so good its sickening.

So is Animal.

but im going In the moonlight because i much rather listen to it these days.

Scratch that. Just watched that video.

Geezes. Remember when ed would just hover over the mic and deliver a performance like that? The kind that drags you off your couch and throws you through the fucking wall?

Geezes.

Its shit like that that where pearl jam has earned the right to do whatever the fuck they want.

There's a reason we're all still here.

In the Moonlight is fucking great.

But Animal is just...next level.

I don't remember, but I can imagine. And watch on Youtube. I love Youtube.

I can. No hesitation at all.

"Animal" is tremendous, but in the end this just isn't the side of the band that's kept me coming back for all these years. It's probably not even in my top 50 honestly. Which isn't meant to be a slight against it -- there's just a lot of other Pearl Jam music that's more closely aligned with my tastes.

Easy vote for "Moonlight."

The seasons they are turnin' and my sad heart is yearnin'
To hear again the songbird's sweet melodious tone

Now that's a matchup that would make me think!

Animal

I respect the hell out of this. Hold the door, my man!