I wonder what percentage of posts of disagreement on this board are textbook examples of the either/or fallacy.

I think my main issue with the drain thing is that it's not even a funny premise. The ep should have ended with Dee saying, "There's goddam AIDS blood in the pool. I hate this water park!"

Mac smiling was one of the funniest things in the episode. You are crazy.

This is one of the few shows that can still pull off the classic Frasier/Seinfeld style of shit piling up and piling up and ultimately culiminating in a big final moment based on the last twenty minutes of precariously-piled-set-up. Dee and Mac landing in the pool full of AIDS water and Mac's sitting on the drain pipe is the perfect example of this. I was laughing.

I mostly loved the Waterpark episode. The subplot with Dennis and the teenage grifter was the best part, I wish they had explored that more. The jokes about the girl chewing through her prolapsed anus were not funny, and they sort of made me queasy. I kind of got anxious imagining being stuck in a waterslide like that. One of the only times this show has made me uncomfortable, but it made the laughs that much better when they came.

My wife is watching The Mick and it is just terrible

It looks terrible.

this show is just ridiculoudsly re-watchable for me

I'm rewatching Dee Made a Smut Film and I'm confused by Lenny's hate. This is a great episode. Frank playing the art dealer is classic.

i liked it better on rewatch...i never hated it, just wasn't enamored with it

i'd definetly put it above frank falls out a window now

Yeah, that episode has a great cold open and a weak everything else.

it was just a lazy retread of past storylines

i really missed rex this season

I thought Charlie acting like Richard Grieco and actually having Richard Grieco in it was the funniest part. And Frank's nazi hallucinations.

Oh and daft twat seems to have never read/heard of "Guts", which I mentioned before he even went off on the "it really happened" argument.

I certainly have not. I read a description. Gross. Christ.

Look, anyone who loves Sunny, and I do, enjoys black humor. I am not saying they went over the line. I just personally didn't find it funny in an episode that I thought was really funny overall. If I had an issue with it, it's that as far as I know, this happened to one kid, so it's a little too specific. Random drowning kid? No problem. That's happened to thousands of kids. Anyway, looking forward to the next ep.

The Nightman Cometh has to be the best episode. Thoughts?

Top 5 for sure.
Chardee McDennis, Dee Dates a Retarded Person, The Gang Dances Their Asses Off also come to mind.

I have to be honest...I really do not like the Chardee MacDennis episodes. I think it easily some of the weakest stuff in the series. It feels like they are just throwing shit at the wall.

Old Lady House was not very good. Couple lols scattered throughout.

Yes.

Or The Gang Dances Their Asses Off.

But, no, yes. It's The Nightman Cometh.

The Nightman Cometh is probably best.

Or Thundergun Express or Mac and Charlie Write a Movie or The Gang Buys a Boat.

I'm probably forgetting some.