Tue May 08, 2018 8:04 pm
PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
Tue May 08, 2018 8:14 pm
Tue May 08, 2018 8:23 pm
tragabigzanda wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
There is nothing remotely original about the DeLeos compositions, but damn if they don't sound awesome. They are two very talented studio/pro songwriters who were smart enough to link up with an amazing singer.
Tue May 08, 2018 8:26 pm
Dev wrote:tragabigzanda wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
There is nothing remotely original about the DeLeos compositions, but damn if they don't sound awesome. They are two very talented studio/pro songwriters who were smart enough to link up with an amazing singer.
That's kind of my point though. Scott could make any rock band sound great.
Tue May 08, 2018 8:28 pm
bune wrote:Dev wrote:tragabigzanda wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
There is nothing remotely original about the DeLeos compositions, but damn if they don't sound awesome. They are two very talented studio/pro songwriters who were smart enough to link up with an amazing singer.
That's kind of my point though. Scott could make any rock band sound great.
The Wildabouts says yes, but Art of Anarchy says no.
Tue May 08, 2018 8:55 pm
Dev wrote:bune wrote:Dev wrote:tragabigzanda wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
There is nothing remotely original about the DeLeos compositions, but damn if they don't sound awesome. They are two very talented studio/pro songwriters who were smart enough to link up with an amazing singer.
That's kind of my point though. Scott could make any rock band sound great.
The Wildabouts says yes, but Art of Anarchy says no.
Hey was past his prime in both of those bands. Seems like he was barely even alive.
Tue May 08, 2018 9:07 pm
Taylor recently admitted that he tried out for the vacant singer spot in the band Velvet Revolver, but said that it just did not work out.[61] However, according to a recent Billboard article, it seems likely that he may in fact become the vocalist for Velvet Revolver, though no official confirmation has been made.[62] Duff McKagan added that they can neither "confirm or deny" Taylor's membership in the band but believes that Taylor is the "real deal".[63] Slash has since ruled Corey out as the possible new vocalist explaining that "[it] just wasn't right" although he does love him.[64] He however, has recorded 10 new songs with the band, drummer Matt Sorum stated it's unlikely it will ever be released.[65]
Tue May 08, 2018 10:23 pm
PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:bune wrote:Dev wrote:tragabigzanda wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
There is nothing remotely original about the DeLeos compositions, but damn if they don't sound awesome. They are two very talented studio/pro songwriters who were smart enough to link up with an amazing singer.
That's kind of my point though. Scott could make any rock band sound great.
The Wildabouts says yes, but Art of Anarchy says no.
Hey was past his prime in both of those bands. Seems like he was barely even alive.
For the most part I thought Velvet Revolver sucked.
Tue May 08, 2018 10:42 pm
Dev wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:bune wrote:Dev wrote:tragabigzanda wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
There is nothing remotely original about the DeLeos compositions, but damn if they don't sound awesome. They are two very talented studio/pro songwriters who were smart enough to link up with an amazing singer.
That's kind of my point though. Scott could make any rock band sound great.
The Wildabouts says yes, but Art of Anarchy says no.
Hey was past his prime in both of those bands. Seems like he was barely even alive.
For the most part I thought Velvet Revolver sucked.
u were wrong
Tue May 08, 2018 10:48 pm
PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:bune wrote:Dev wrote:tragabigzanda wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
There is nothing remotely original about the DeLeos compositions, but damn if they don't sound awesome. They are two very talented studio/pro songwriters who were smart enough to link up with an amazing singer.
That's kind of my point though. Scott could make any rock band sound great.
The Wildabouts says yes, but Art of Anarchy says no.
Hey was past his prime in both of those bands. Seems like he was barely even alive.
For the most part I thought Velvet Revolver sucked.
u were wrong
Convince me
Tue May 08, 2018 10:51 pm
Dev wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:bune wrote:Dev wrote:tragabigzanda wrote:PHATJ wrote:Dev wrote:I blame Scott for nothing. He made the the band. They are lucky he was able to drag them along for as long as he did.
That’s not entirely true. The DeLeo brothers wrote almost all of the music. Obviously Scott was a great front man, and his melodies and voice and stage presence were a HUGE part of STP’s success. But I genuinely believe that Scott needed Robert and Dean almost as much as they needed him. Again, without the DeLeo’s there aren’t the songs.
There is nothing remotely original about the DeLeos compositions, but damn if they don't sound awesome. They are two very talented studio/pro songwriters who were smart enough to link up with an amazing singer.
That's kind of my point though. Scott could make any rock band sound great.
The Wildabouts says yes, but Art of Anarchy says no.
Hey was past his prime in both of those bands. Seems like he was barely even alive.
For the most part I thought Velvet Revolver sucked.
u were wrong
Convince me
just listen to the albums and pay attention to Scott's dancing.
Wed May 09, 2018 2:02 am
Wed May 09, 2018 2:11 am
Kalevi wrote:Scott's solo albums are pretty great
Wed May 09, 2018 4:00 pm
Wed May 09, 2018 5:14 pm
i got bugs wrote:I thought they sounded great last night.. place was packed.. I was wondering the % of people who didn't even know that wasn't Scott singing..
I honestly thought the new songs even sounded really good.. I think I like that album better than the last self titled
I think I was the most pumped person in the building when they busted out Atlanta.. my buddy was pumped for piece of pie, which is the song he nailed at the audition to get the gig.. also I thought it was neat he credited glide as his favorite stp song
Wed May 09, 2018 8:08 pm
Wed May 09, 2018 10:54 pm
Thu June 14, 2018 1:14 am
bart wrote:bada wrote:Kretz: The line in the song about dogs is basically because dogs have always fascinated me because their sense of smell is so incredible. If someone comes to your house and walks around the corner, they don't have to see you, but they can still smell the scent. I put that part in there because of the uncertainty of who's going to be around when we're gone, what's going to be happening and how much everyone in the band loved dogs, how much we loved having dogs there for watchdogs and certain types of protection. They were man's best friend. And yeah, that's kind of an odd thing but it all made sense at the time. With the mask in the lyrics, it was around the Day of the Dead – the Mexican festival – and there's a lot of masks. We were always excited about ethnic art. If you look at ethnic art, masks are such a big part of it. It could come from a million places.
Thu June 14, 2018 10:52 am
Thu June 14, 2018 3:26 pm
bart wrote:bart wrote:bada wrote:Kretz: The line in the song about dogs is basically because dogs have always fascinated me because their sense of smell is so incredible. If someone comes to your house and walks around the corner, they don't have to see you, but they can still smell the scent. I put that part in there because of the uncertainty of who's going to be around when we're gone, what's going to be happening and how much everyone in the band loved dogs, how much we loved having dogs there for watchdogs and certain types of protection. They were man's best friend. And yeah, that's kind of an odd thing but it all made sense at the time. With the mask in the lyrics, it was around the Day of the Dead – the Mexican festival – and there's a lot of masks. We were always excited about ethnic art. If you look at ethnic art, masks are such a big part of it. It could come from a million places.
I still think about this paragraph sometimes.