I mentioned that one in particular because Neil and the band were famously indulging in a lot of drugs and alcohol throughout the recording process. And the songs are very rough -- moreso than usual.

I don't know if there are actually any mistakes (as I said, I'd have to listen again), or if you'd even call them mistakes since that's kind of part of the spirit of the record, but yeah.

yeah true, just raw af. love the horse.

Is it the horse without poncho though?

I don't think Tonight's the Night is a Crazy Horse album, is it?

It's not. I know Nils Lofgren plays on it, but I'm not sure who else.

It's not credited as such but...

The band assembled for the album was known as The Santa Monica Flyers. It consisted of Young, Ben Keith, Nils Lofgren, and the Crazy Horse rhythm section of Billy Talbot and Ralph Molina. One track as stated above was taken from recordings of an earlier tour with Crazy Horse, and another from an earlier session with his band for Harvest, The Stray Gators.

it's david gilmour coughing, and supposedly when he heard it it prompted him to quit smoking for good.

A performance error: the Elvis Costello & The Imposters song "Go Away" features two drummers playing at the same time, Pete Thomas and his daughter Tennessee Thomas (from the bands The Like and Nice as Fuck). At 3:40, one of the drummers jumps into the chorus early while the other holds the verse groove, creating a cool little awkward moment of forward momentum before correcting itself after a few measures

it has the core horse rhythm section and's about a horse member and roadie dying of drugs. it's a horse album.

I agree.

It IS super subtle, and I didn't realize just how subtle until after I posted about it. The only reason I ever knew about it is because Peter Buck had said something about it in an interview, and I think in my mind I must have tricked my memory into thinking it was more noticeable.

Mine was the only legit and good one.

It's a different band called The Santa Monica Flyers that happened to have some members of the horse in it.

So it's not the horse. Sorry.

It's like saying Temple Of The Dog is really just a Pearl Jam album.

Did anyone mention on riot act, that weird electronic noise and someone goin ‘neh neh neh neh neh neh neh’ before Can’t Keep?

This is a good one. Also the intro of Red Mosquito.

Neither of these are production errors, glitches or mistakes.

This. It's just studio chatter they intentionally left in.

Well then so is the ‘mistake’ 1234 at the start of brain of j..
There’s probably few rare occasdions of genuine mistakes that were missed, on any album.
They’d mostly be things the band and producer decided to leave on.

The way I see it, there are a few different things that could go in this thread:

- Performance mistakes that don't get corrected due to time or budget constraints (or just go unnoticed), such as Wease's Steely Dan example
- "Happy accidents" that the band + producer decide to leave in (like Morello's guitar picking up that Korean radio station in the OP)
- Production glitches (sloppy edits, autotune errors, random digital beeps and stuff like squeaky kick drums, etc)

The recurring theme is that they're accidental, even if the band has decided to leave them in after the fact. Both the "duh-nuhnuhnuh" at the start of "Can't Keep" and the "12341234!" at the start of "Brain of J" sound deliberate to me