Is first impression ultimately most accurate?

Accurate to what?

Reality

The reality of what? Whether you like a song or not?

The true, objective value

What's the point of this thread, exactly?

songs change, evolve.. I didn't get pink rabbits and most the national songs upon first listens then I grew to love them... Why is that? I'm beginning to wonder if I actually never began to like their songs but for some reason decided to believe I did

No such thing, this thread is dumb

Tree would have a third of his posts if he got to the point from the start.

I'm not going to do it to save you modding time, but the obvious answer is so that someone will create a companion thread titled "Showers?"

I like this thread.

Growers are for smart people who have class.

And then one called "Baths?"

Songs sometimes need to marinate in the brain before the thing that gets you about them reveals themselves. Others you love right away.

Or you could just be talking about dicks and fix and file things.

No.

Music that is not obviously catchy (or rigid in terms of tempo and time signatures) can take some time to reveal itself.

The ultimate example of this would be "Trout Mask Replica".

The aural equivalent of a "seeing eye" puzzle.