The board's server will undergo upgrade maintenance tonight, Nov 5, 2014, beginning approximately around 10 PM ET. Prepare for some possible down time during this process.
Post subject: Re: Lets Actually Listen to the Album: Vitalogy
Posted: Fri December 27, 2013 10:01 pm
10Club Complaint Department
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm Posts: 17337
_________________
RisingTides wrote:
There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Post subject: Re: Lets Actually Listen to the Album: Vitalogy
Posted: Fri December 27, 2013 10:07 pm
The worst
Joined: Thu December 13, 2012 6:31 pm Posts: 39951
digster wrote:
stip wrote:
digster wrote:
stip wrote:
digster wrote:
I feel like Vitalogy may end in the bleakest spot of any of their records. I wouldn't deny there's a fighting spirit at the beginning, but by the time Stupid Mop sputters out, it seems like there's nothing left of it. It was kind of shocking when I listened to the album straight through most recently; in isolation the songs sound more hopeful then tracing it from start to end.
I'm not sure I agree. Betterman and satan's because have some fight in them, and immortality doesn't end with the desolate sound it starts with. I may be unfairly excluding stupid mop. On the other hand, maybe it is significant that it is the only song not in eddies voice
I think it's definitely a progression, although Better Man's up-tempo sound always struck me as mocking as opposed to a call to 'keep fighting' as it were (after all, the songs ends with the character repeating over and over, "can't find a better man," absolutely a sign that she's given up). However, by the time you get past to Immortality and Stupid Mop, things are pretty relentlessly bleak. I think that's why Ave Davanita, and it's placement, is no accident. It separates those last two songs into the final 'chapter' of the record.
I have no problem with that bleakness, by the way. They've ended some of their other records in similar spots and they've been great endings as well.
That's reasonable, bit I still hear Betterman as refusing to give up on the hope of something better even with no out in sight. And while immortality is a dark song it ends on that moment of indecision, and while stupid mop is hopelessly bleak with strong intimations of suicide it is still, I think, significant, that the song is not in eddies voice. Sort of a 'there but for the grace of god go I/road not taken outcome. A warning, not a prophecy. Where you end up if you stop pushing the rock.
I think Betterman may have had a similar thing as happened to Alive; it's a dark song on record, but live the anthemic quality of it shifted the perception of the song. Lyrically, it's hard for me to hear the ending of that song as anything other than a total defeat and surrender; "she feeds him, that's why she'll be back again...can't find a better man."
And I always heard Immortality as being pretty final when it's last lyrics hit. The truant comes up on a fork in the road in the last verse, but it ends with "truants move on, cannot stay long, some die just to live." The jam at the end feels like the decision's been made, and the character is just floating into the ether. To me, it's the darkest ending to a PJ record besides maybe All or None. And then Stupid Mop takes you out of the ether and puts you in hell. The length of the song, and the fact that there's little to grab onto, makes it feel evocative of eternity.
Or something like that.
it's a song, though, so the music should be giving you some interpreitive hints regarding how to understand the lyrics, and so the born to runesque crescendo at the end of betterman certainly colors how I read the song.
and like I said, that's a pretty reasonable read on immortality--it's just not mine. the final statement of immortality is still posed ambiguously, embodies a defeatist attitude that runs counter (and in a way that is something of a sudden 180) to much of the rest of the record, and the moments that follow are not in the main character's voice.
MattA75 wrote:
stip wrote:
digster wrote:
stip wrote:
digster wrote:
I feel like Vitalogy may end in the bleakest spot of any of their records. I wouldn't deny there's a fighting spirit at the beginning, but by the time Stupid Mop sputters out, it seems like there's nothing left of it. It was kind of shocking when I listened to the album straight through most recently; in isolation the songs sound more hopeful then tracing it from start to end.
I'm not sure I agree. Betterman and satan's because have some fight in them, and immortality doesn't end with the desolate sound it starts with. I may be unfairly excluding stupid mop. On the other hand, maybe it is significant that it is the only song not in eddies voice
I think it's definitely a progression, although Better Man's up-tempo sound always struck me as mocking as opposed to a call to 'keep fighting' as it were (after all, the songs ends with the character repeating over and over, "can't find a better man," absolutely a sign that she's given up). However, by the time you get past to Immortality and Stupid Mop, things are pretty relentlessly bleak. I think that's why Ave Davanita, and it's placement, is no accident. It separates those last two songs into the final 'chapter' of the record.
I have no problem with that bleakness, by the way. They've ended some of their other records in similar spots and they've been great endings as well.
That's reasonable, bit I still hear Betterman as refusing to give up on the hope of something better even with no out in sight. And while immortality is a dark song it ends on that moment of indecision, and while stupid mop is hopelessly bleak with strong intimations of suicide it is still, I think, significant, that the song is not in eddies voice. Sort of a 'there but for the grace of god go I/road not taken outcome. A warning, not a prophecy. Where you end up if you stop pushing the rock.
would you feel the same way about Better Man if it were the organ/vocal version from the Vitalogy re-issue?
Post subject: Re: Lets Actually Listen to the Album: Vitalogy
Posted: Fri December 27, 2013 10:10 pm
tl;dr
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 6:06 pm Posts: 8569
RM should have a contest where posters are all required to join a dating site, the only requirement being that everyone's profile picture has to be a terrible picture of him or herself holding up a piece of notebook paper with Pearl Jam lyrics written on it. First one to get a date gets first prize, and so forth.
Post subject: Re: Lets Actually Listen to the Album: Vitalogy
Posted: Fri December 27, 2013 10:23 pm
Rank This Poster
Joined: Thu January 03, 2013 1:10 am Posts: 3880
stip wrote:
it's a song, though, so the music should be giving you some interpreitive hints regarding how to understand the lyrics, and so the born to runesque crescendo at the end of betterman certainly colors how I read the song.
and like I said, that's a pretty reasonable read on immortality--it's just not mine. the final statement of immortality is still posed ambiguously, embodies a defeatist attitude that runs counter (and in a way that is something of a sudden 180) to much of the rest of the record, and the moments that follow are not in the main character's voice.
Well, I'd agree that the music should give hints; it does. I think the pairing of such a dark sentiment with the poppy music heightens how sad and ironic the end of that song is. As for Immortality, yeah, we just disagree on that one. I see how someone could feel the ending music could take the edge off the final lyric.
Post subject: Re: Lets Actually Listen to the Album: Vitalogy
Posted: Fri December 27, 2013 11:17 pm
Commissioner
Joined: Wed March 13, 2013 12:48 am Posts: 11792
Kevin Davis wrote:
RM should have a contest where posters are all required to join a dating site, the only requirement being that everyone's profile picture has to be a terrible picture of him or herself holding up a piece of notebook paper with Pearl Jam lyrics written on it. First one to get a date gets first prize, and so forth.
I'm gonna update my profile picture to one of me holding a sign that says "Love boat captain, take the reigns..." and report back. I just need to find a Captain's hat to wear in the photo.
Post subject: Re: Lets Actually Listen to the Album: Vitalogy
Posted: Fri December 27, 2013 11:21 pm
10Club Complaint Department
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm Posts: 17337
Steer us t'ward the eclair.
_________________
RisingTides wrote:
There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
Post subject: Re: Lets Actually Listen to the Album: Vitalogy
Posted: Fri December 27, 2013 11:31 pm
10Club Complaint Department
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:41 pm Posts: 17337
Kaius wrote:
Pleasantly plump
_________________
RisingTides wrote:
There is more kindness on the internet than we would care to admit to ourselves. Sometimes we are so afraid of falling victim to a ruse, we miss out on actual opportunities.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum