Mon July 29, 2013 5:12 pm
Ledbetterdays wrote:
Will they give us what we want or will they....something else?
Mon July 29, 2013 5:21 pm
harmless wrote:Ledbetterdays wrote:"Can No Longer Mind My Manners"
I've got an unfortunate feeling
we'll be let down
Pearl Jam will disappoint again
with all the new songs coming out
What they've taken is more than a vow
Their taking 5 star songs again and throwing them on a burning pile yeah yeah hay hay
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
I caught myself believing I needed Lightning Bolt
and if its out there somewhere we sure could use it now
Tried my patience, my patience tried
Ten, Yield, No Code and I'm done and it makes me want to cry
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
Outtakes are playing...
Self-realized in two thousand and three
May not be another hit may not matter as much to me
right around the corner could be bigger than we think
Will they give us what we want or will they....something else?
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
Outtakes are playing...
Self-realized in two thousand and three
May not be another hit may not matter as much to me
Right around the corner could be bigger than we think
Will they give us what we want or will they....something else?
Go to Brendan O'Brien
That's swell
How You Like You're
Pop Punk Hell
Go to Brendan O'Brien
That's swell
How You Like You're
Pop Punk Hell
Pop Punk Hell
Your*
Also, you gave up at No Code?
Mon July 29, 2013 5:23 pm
Thejambi wrote:harmless wrote:Ledbetterdays wrote:"Can No Longer Mind My Manners"
I've got an unfortunate feeling
we'll be let down
Pearl Jam will disappoint again
with all the new songs coming out
What they've taken is more than a vow
Their taking 5 star songs again and throwing them on a burning pile yeah yeah hay hay
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
I caught myself believing I needed Lightning Bolt
and if its out there somewhere we sure could use it now
Tried my patience, my patience tried
Ten, Yield, No Code and I'm done and it makes me want to cry
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
Outtakes are playing...
Self-realized in two thousand and three
May not be another hit may not matter as much to me
right around the corner could be bigger than we think
Will they give us what we want or will they....something else?
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
Outtakes are playing...
Self-realized in two thousand and three
May not be another hit may not matter as much to me
Right around the corner could be bigger than we think
Will they give us what we want or will they....something else?
Go to Brendan O'Brien
That's swell
How You Like You're
Pop Punk Hell
Go to Brendan O'Brien
That's swell
How You Like You're
Pop Punk Hell
Pop Punk Hell
Your*
Also, you gave up at No Code?
So derivative .
Mon July 29, 2013 7:31 pm
Ledbetterdays wrote:"Can No Longer Mind My Manners"
I've got an unfortunate feeling
we'll be let down
Pearl Jam will disappoint again
with all the new songs coming out
What they've taken is more than a vow
Their taking 5 star songs again and throwing them on a burning pile yeah yeah hay hay
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
I caught myself believing I needed Lightning Bolt
and if its out there somewhere we sure could use it now
Tried my patience, my patience tried
Ten, Yield, No Code and I'm done and it makes me want to cry
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
Outtakes are playing...
Self-realized in two thousand and three
May not be another hit may not matter as much to me
right around the corner could be bigger than we think
Will they give us what we want or will they....something else?
And to the fans they are saying
Mind Your Manners
Outtakes are playing...
Self-realized in two thousand and three
May not be another hit may not matter as much to me
Right around the corner could be bigger than we think
Will they give us what we want or will they....something else?
Go to Brendan O'Brien
That's swell
How You Like You're
Pop Punk Hell
Go to Brendan O'Brien
That's swell
How You Like You're
Pop Punk Hell
Pop Punk Hell
Mon July 29, 2013 11:01 pm
Ledbetterdays wrote:"Can No Longer Mind My Manners"
Mon July 29, 2013 11:11 pm
Sgt. Crackpot wrote:Ledbetterdays wrote:"Can No Longer Mind My Manners"
Tue July 30, 2013 1:49 am
Tue July 30, 2013 11:51 am
Tue July 30, 2013 12:09 pm
harmless wrote:LB and FD will live or die in the studio.
Tue July 30, 2013 12:11 pm
Gob wrote:Been a while since I've posted here, so forgot my info and had to start from scratch, but..
I'm looking all over the web and can't find these songs. Can anyone help me out?
Tue July 30, 2013 12:32 pm
Blenheim Augustine wrote:harmless wrote:LB and FD will live or die in the studio.
Problem is the songs won't get better - the versions I've heard are pretty clean live versions of the songs and we can assume that they are being played as arranged on the album and recently rehearsed.
I remember hearing Red Mosquito, Lukin and Brain of JFK before they were studio versions and I loved them and then loved the studio versions. Some songs do work better as studio only songs but you can't polish a turd - some dripping water, a hot Asian playing violin and thunder noises won't make that much of a difference.
Tue July 30, 2013 12:33 pm
Blenheim Augustine wrote:harmless wrote:LB and FD will live or die in the studio.
Problem is the songs won't get better - the versions I've heard are pretty clean live versions of the songs and we can assume that they are being played as arranged on the album and recently rehearsed.
Blenheim Augustine wrote:I remember hearing Red Mosquito, Lukin and Brain of JFK before they were studio versions and I loved them and then loved the studio versions. Some songs do work better as studio only songs but you can't polish a turd - some dripping water, a hot Asian playing violin and thunder noises won't make that much of a difference.
Tue July 30, 2013 12:37 pm
Tue July 30, 2013 12:57 pm
harmless wrote:As for 'We can assume that they are being played as arranged on the album and recently rehearsed', where do you get this from? I don't assume any of that, because as I said, PJ don't play anything live in a way which is faithful to the studio version.
Tue July 30, 2013 1:04 pm
Blenheim Augustine wrote:harmless wrote:As for 'We can assume that they are being played as arranged on the album and recently rehearsed', where do you get this from? I don't assume any of that, because as I said, PJ don't play anything live in a way which is faithful to the studio version.
You wouldn't think they would have rehearsed brand new songs before debuting them to 40,000 people and knowing that they will be strewn across the internet within a matter of seconds?
Blenheim Augustine wrote:I'm also not sure of songs where there is such a difference between live and studio. I can think of a few examples such as Low Light but in terms of recent output the stuff on Avocado mostly sounded better live - Backspacer was crap to begin with but the songs still come across live. The example you give of RVM, I understand that there is a marginally different arrangement, but RVM still sounds awesome live and if Lightning Bolt was the equivalent of that then nobody would be saying it was a 3 star song.
I'm not saying there won't be differences - I just don't think people's 'star ratings' will change much on hearing a studio version.
Tue July 30, 2013 1:40 pm
Thejambi wrote:I think both are solid songs. Neither is a turd.
Tue July 30, 2013 1:44 pm
McParadigm wrote:Thejambi wrote:I think both are solid songs. Neither is a turd.
No. It pretty much takes both those songs combined to equate to one fully formed dollop of poop.
Tue July 30, 2013 1:51 pm
Tue July 30, 2013 1:52 pm
harmless wrote:McParadigm wrote:Thejambi wrote:I think both are solid songs. Neither is a turd.
No. It pretty much takes both those songs combined to equate to one fully formed dollop of poop.
Tue July 30, 2013 3:46 pm
McParadigm wrote:Thejambi wrote:I think both are solid songs. Neither is a turd.
No. It pretty much takes both those songs combined to equate to one fully formed dollop of poop.