The board's server will undergo upgrade maintenance tonight, Nov 5, 2014, beginning approximately around 10 PM ET. Prepare for some possible down time during this process.
Joined: Tue September 24, 2013 5:56 pm Posts: 47165 Location: In the oatmeal aisle wearing a Shellac shirt
I don't think there are any bad lyrics on this album. They're all par for the course at this point for Ed -- some ocean references, some nature stuff, some cosmos stuff, some weary traveler stuff -- and then a handful of lines that are deeply compelling (some written by Jeff or Stone or maybe Matt).
Outside of a handful of older songs -- Present Tense, Amongst The Waves, Gone, a few others -- I just accept Ed's lyrics for what they are: Decent, but taken to some great heights when his vocal performance is on-point.
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 3:35 pm Posts: 32290 Location: Buenos Aires
tragabigzanda wrote:
I don't think there are any bad lyrics on this album. They're all par for the course at this point for Ed -- some ocean references, some nature stuff, some cosmos stuff, some weary traveler stuff
I'm not talking about the themes or the sentiments. What I really bristle at with a lot of latter-day PJ songs is the construction of some lines. Ed just has a natural tendency towards verbosity and clunkiness of language, and this shows up all through the album, even in songs that are otherwise lyrically powerful. See, for example, "Sadness comes, with it a sea of tears, would some love be best had it not appeared"
Joined: Thu December 13, 2012 6:31 pm Posts: 39916
theplatypus wrote:
tragabigzanda wrote:
I don't think there are any bad lyrics on this album. They're all par for the course at this point for Ed -- some ocean references, some nature stuff, some cosmos stuff, some weary traveler stuff
I'm not talking about the themes or the sentiments. What I really bristle at with a lot of latter-day PJ songs is the construction of some lines. Ed just has a natural tendency towards verbosity and clunkiness of language, and this shows up all through the album, even in songs that are otherwise lyrically powerful. See, for example, "Sadness comes, with it a sea of tears, would some love be best had it not appeared"
That's been a staple of his writing almost from jump, accordingly. It leads to his best and worst work.
Joined: Sun January 26, 2020 12:10 pm Posts: 12128 Location: Warwickshire, UK
if I was going to be kind to that line, I would say it's an attempt to subvert the cliche "better to have loved and lost, than never to have lost at all"; but Ed is punching above his weight with Shakespeare
I don't think there are any bad lyrics on this album. They're all par for the course at this point for Ed -- some ocean references, some nature stuff, some cosmos stuff, some weary traveler stuff
I'm not talking about the themes or the sentiments. What I really bristle at with a lot of latter-day PJ songs is the construction of some lines. Ed just has a natural tendency towards verbosity and clunkiness of language, and this shows up all through the album, even in songs that are otherwise lyrically powerful. See, for example, "Sadness comes, with it a sea of tears, would some love be best had it not appeared"
I guess I like the clunkiness. If the lyrics always flow together perfectly I find they may get a bit stale/boring/predictable for me.
Joined: Thu December 13, 2012 6:31 pm Posts: 39916
Ms Harmless wrote:
if I was going to be kind to that line, I would say it's an attempt to subvert the cliche "better to have loved and lost, than never to have lost at all"; but Ed is punching above his weight with Shakespeare
Joined: Sun January 26, 2020 12:10 pm Posts: 12128 Location: Warwickshire, UK
stip wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
if I was going to be kind to that line, I would say it's an attempt to subvert the cliche "better to have loved and lost, than never to have lost at all"; but Ed is punching above his weight with Shakespeare
Joined: Tue September 24, 2013 5:56 pm Posts: 47165 Location: In the oatmeal aisle wearing a Shellac shirt
Leatherhead wrote:
theplatypus wrote:
tragabigzanda wrote:
I don't think there are any bad lyrics on this album. They're all par for the course at this point for Ed -- some ocean references, some nature stuff, some cosmos stuff, some weary traveler stuff
I'm not talking about the themes or the sentiments. What I really bristle at with a lot of latter-day PJ songs is the construction of some lines. Ed just has a natural tendency towards verbosity and clunkiness of language, and this shows up all through the album, even in songs that are otherwise lyrically powerful. See, for example, "Sadness comes, with it a sea of tears, would some love be best had it not appeared"
I guess I like the clunkiness. If the lyrics always flow together perfectly I find they may get a bit stale/boring/predictable for me.
I'm continuing this conversation in the gigaton thread:
I think the lyrics are being unfairly maligned here, maybe because some of us have no need for the message
I think you could just as easily flip this and say that identifying with the message makes one more likely to conflate the content of the message with good writing. This happens with overtly topical music a lot, people stuggling to separate the quality of the work itself from the degree to which they agree or disagree with what it's saying.
I don't think it's deafness to the song's message that is causing me to think, for example, that "If you grow tired of the game/Hit the road towards the clouds/Find the groove in the sound" is an obvious, uncreative metaphor. The acid trip line just feels overly literal and inappropriate for the song. There may be worse lyrics elsewhere on the album, but for whatever reason these are the ones that have jumped out at me. And I still enjoy the song despite them.
Joined: Sun January 26, 2020 12:10 pm Posts: 12128 Location: Warwickshire, UK
Kevin Davis wrote:
Ms Harmless wrote:
I think the lyrics are being unfairly maligned here, maybe because some of us have no need for the message
I think you could just as easily flip this and say that identifying with the message makes you more likely to conflate the content of the message with good writing. This happens with overtly topical music a lot, people stuggling to separate the quality of the work itself from the degree to which they agree or disagree with what it's saying.
I don't think it's deafness to the song's message that is causing me to think, for example, that "If you grow tired of the game/Hit the road towards the clouds/Find the groove in the sound" is an obvious, uncreative metaphor. The acid trip line just feels overly literal and inappropriate for the song. There may be worse lyrics elsewhere on the album, but for whatever reason these are the ones that have jumped out at me. And I still enjoy the song despite them.
I think PJ (and rock music in general) has a ceiling when it comes to lyrical creativity and originality; I go to them for emotional resonance
Joined: Sun January 26, 2020 12:10 pm Posts: 12128 Location: Warwickshire, UK
if the lyrics here don't grab you, I totally understand, but this song resonates with me emotionally and that's all I need from it; I don't think there's a single decent Pearl Jam song that doesn't make use of cliches
I think PJ (and rock music in general) has a ceiling when it comes to lyrical creativity and originality
Probably, but this song isn't even sort of hitting it.
Again, no disrespect if you dig the lyrics or identify with them. We all react differently to songs for different reasons, this is just one of the things that holds this song back for me. And, again, I do still enjoy it.
Joined: Sun January 26, 2020 12:10 pm Posts: 12128 Location: Warwickshire, UK
in my opinion, it's not cliche that's the problem, it's more the mixture of abstract and concrete imagery; but there isn't a single PJ song without that issue ("three crooked hearts, swirls all around")
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum