The board's server will undergo upgrade maintenance tonight, Nov 5, 2014, beginning approximately around 10 PM ET. Prepare for some possible down time during this process.
Concert 1 Let’s Go Crazy/ Endorphinemachine/ Screwdriver/ She’s Always in My Hair/ The Love We Make/ I Could Never Take the Place of Your Man/ Guitar/ Plectum Electrum (new instrumental written by 3rdeyegirl’s Donna Grantis)/ Fix Ur Life Up/ medley of snippets from: When Doves Cry > Sign o’ the Times> Most Beautiful Girl in the World > Forever in My Life> Hot Thing> A Love Bizarre > Housequake/ Mr. Goodnight/ Purple Rain (with Bobby Z on drums) ENCORE Even Flow (Pearl Jam, instrumental version)/ Bambi ENCORE 2 Stratus (Billy Cobham instrumental)/ U Got the Look
Concert 2 Let’s Go Crazy/ Endrophinemachine/ Screwdriver/ She’s Always in My Hair/ Free/ I Could Never Take the Place of Your Man/ Guitar/ Plectum Electrum (new instrumental written by 3rdeyegirl’s Donna Grantis)/ Fix Ur Life Up/ I Like It There/ So Far So Please/ Stratus (Billy Cobham instrumental) ENCORE Purple Rain (with Bobby Z on drums)/ The Max/ Laydown ENCORE 2 Even Flow (Pearl Jam, instrumental version)
if any video/audio gets out there, we'll have to consider ourselves lucky- prince is notorious for not allowing recordings and taking anything down online that was recorded.
_________________ ah, copperplate, a font for the truly modern man.
That was, meh whatever. The word that comes to mind is 'common". The funny thing is if someone posted that snippet and didn't say it was Prince then it would get like 3 responses, but since it's Prince you all are beating off to it. Hilarious. Prince along with Cobain are the most over-rated guitar players ever.
I don't think I've ever heard anyone call Kurt Cobain a great guitar player.
Joined: Tue January 01, 2013 2:04 pm Posts: 37156 Location: September 2020 Poster of the Month
Kevin Davis wrote:
gems and rhinestones wrote:
That was, meh whatever. The word that comes to mind is 'common". The funny thing is if someone posted that snippet and didn't say it was Prince then it would get like 3 responses, but since it's Prince you all are beating off to it. Hilarious. Prince along with Cobain are the most over-rated guitar players ever.
I don't think I've ever heard anyone call Kurt Cobain a great guitar player.
Yeah I'm pretty sure no one has ever said that about Kurt Cobain.
That was, meh whatever. The word that comes to mind is 'common". The funny thing is if someone posted that snippet and didn't say it was Prince then it would get like 3 responses, but since it's Prince you all are beating off to it. Hilarious. Prince along with Cobain are the most over-rated guitar players ever.
I don't think I've ever heard anyone call Kurt Cobain a great guitar player.
Yeah I'm pretty sure no one has ever said that about Kurt Cobain.
Well some magazines called him one of the greatest guitar players from all times and bla bla....but whatever Prince is incredible and that´s about it.
Joined: Thu December 13, 2012 6:31 pm Posts: 39932
VinylGuy wrote:
cutuphalfdead wrote:
Kevin Davis wrote:
gems and rhinestones wrote:
That was, meh whatever. The word that comes to mind is 'common". The funny thing is if someone posted that snippet and didn't say it was Prince then it would get like 3 responses, but since it's Prince you all are beating off to it. Hilarious. Prince along with Cobain are the most over-rated guitar players ever.
I don't think I've ever heard anyone call Kurt Cobain a great guitar player.
Yeah I'm pretty sure no one has ever said that about Kurt Cobain.
Well some magazines called him one of the greatest guitar players from all times and bla bla....but whatever Prince is incredible and that´s about it.
Kurt Cobain ALWAYS shows up very high in all those best guitar player lists in magazines and major websites. I am not saying he should be there (he shouldn't) but it's constant
I Googled this and found Rolling Stone's last list of greatest guitarists, where Cobain placed 73rd--hardly much of a showing, but he's on the list, which is more than I'd expected:
Quote:
73 Kurt Cobain
He was no virtuoso, and that's the whole point: By snatching electric guitar from note-shredding technicians and giving it back to artists, freaks and poets, Kurt Cobain became one of the most important players ever. Cobain didn't invent alt-rock. But with his love of Cheap Trick, the Melvins and Kiss, he gave it the metallic power necessary to conquer the world. His playing wasn't all untutored squall, either: See the unconventional chord progression and mastery of quiet-loud-quiet dynamics on "Lithium" – and pretty much every other Nirvana song.
Their premise is essentially that he was a great guitar player because he wasn't a very good guitar player and got very famous for it.
I think this is the 2,214th time someone has posted that RRHOF clip when talking about Prince's guitar playing. It's the only clip anyone ever produces. I actually forgot to say in my original post "I wonder how long til someone posts the clip of Prince with Tom Petty".
As for Cobain, he's almost always in every top 10 list as the greatest of all time. He sucked, but when you kill yourself......TOP 10 in everything!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Were it not for Cobain, I would never have picked up a guitar. I'm sure there's countless kids who grew up at the same time who would say the same. I've always thought his high placement on lists of that nature was a nod to his immense influence rather than an assessment of his technical mastery. I still think he was a really interesting and characterful guitarist, morseso than someone like McCready.
Were it not for Cobain, I would never have picked up a guitar. I'm sure there's countless kids who grew up at the same time who would say the same. I've always thought his high placement on lists of that nature was a nod to his immense influence rather than an assessment of his technical mastery.
I guess I just feel like this kind of defeats the purpose (futile as it is anyway) of a "greatest guitarists" list. Not that it should be all about sheer technical mastery, but once "influence" becomes relevant criteria, the exercise ceases to be an analysis of guitar playing and simply becomes an analysis of cultural iconography--which is fine, but a different list.
Joined: Thu December 13, 2012 6:31 pm Posts: 39932
Kevin Davis wrote:
Quote:
Were it not for Cobain, I would never have picked up a guitar. I'm sure there's countless kids who grew up at the same time who would say the same. I've always thought his high placement on lists of that nature was a nod to his immense influence rather than an assessment of his technical mastery.
I guess I just feel like this kind of defeats the purpose (futile as it is anyway) of a "greatest guitarists" list. Not that it should be all about sheer technical mastery, but once "influence" becomes relevant criteria, the exercise ceases to be an analysis of guitar playing and simply becomes an analysis of cultural iconography--which is fine, but a different list.
Yea i dont think his influence had anything to do with him as a guitarist but rather him writing songs and being in a band at the right place at the right time. What he was doing on guitar was no different than a million others at the same time. Nirvana hit it big and he was the poster boy for that type of playing - which is great - but he is extremely over rated even in that regard. So many other bands and song writers were doing what he did - and I think better - than Kurt.
But whatever. He did get a sort of minimalist punk rock approach to guitar to the mainstream after the ridiculousness of the 80's mainstream players.
Yea i dont think his influence had anything to do with him as a guitarist but rather him writing songs and being in a band at the right place at the right time. What he was doing on guitar was no different than a million others at the same time. Nirvana hit it big and he was the poster boy for that type of playing - which is great - but he is extremely over rated even in that regard. So many other bands and song writers were doing what he did - and I think better - than Kurt.
But whatever. He did get a sort of minimalist punk rock approach to guitar to the mainstream after the ridiculousness of the 80's mainstream players.
Pretty much my thoughts for Nirvana. Billy Corgan said that cobain was a better guitar player but he didnt want to play too much because of that punk creed he was after.
I think this is the 2,214th time someone has posted that RRHOF clip when talking about Prince's guitar playing. It's the only clip anyone ever produces. I actually forgot to say in my original post "I wonder how long til someone posts the clip of Prince with Tom Petty".
As for Cobain, he's almost always in every top 10 list as the greatest of all time. He sucked, but when you kill yourself......TOP 10 in everything!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Cheerio
Here. Just My Imagination. From the legendary "Small Club 1988" bootleg.
I think this is the 2,214th time someone has posted that RRHOF clip when talking about Prince's guitar playing. It's the only clip anyone ever produces. I actually forgot to say in my original post "I wonder how long til someone posts the clip of Prince with Tom Petty".
As for Cobain, he's almost always in every top 10 list as the greatest of all time. He sucked, but when you kill yourself......TOP 10 in everything!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Cheerio
I'd just like to point out that I googled "top ten guitarists" and read the first page of results and Cobain wasn't in any of the lists.
Those lists used to have the obvious guys near the top then the rest would be whoever was popular at the time. For instance in 1987 CC Deville would be like 75 and now he wouldn't be in the top 500. As time goes by and the guitar heroes dried up and things became more stagnant. I imagine Jack White would be one of the youngest on there. They would probably reach and put John Mayer just to have someone current. Maybe there is some obscure jam band kid I never heard of. Funny thing though is I've noticed Eddie Van Halen who might be as high as 2 back in the day has really fallen lately. I think I saw him in the 30's last year.
Last edited by bada on Tue May 28, 2013 3:06 am, edited 1 time in total.
I Googled this and found Rolling Stone's last list of greatest guitarists, where Cobain placed 73rd--hardly much of a showing, but he's on the list, which is more than I'd expected:
Quote:
73 Kurt Cobain
He was no virtuoso, and that's the whole point: By snatching electric guitar from note-shredding technicians and giving it back to artists, freaks and poets, Kurt Cobain became one of the most important players ever. Cobain didn't invent alt-rock. But with his love of Cheap Trick, the Melvins and Kiss, he gave it the metallic power necessary to conquer the world. His playing wasn't all untutored squall, either: See the unconventional chord progression and mastery of quiet-loud-quiet dynamics on "Lithium" – and pretty much every other Nirvana song.
Their premise is essentially that he was a great guitar player because he wasn't a very good guitar player and got very famous for it.
Yeah, it's Rolling Stone....
They do shit like that to create controversy and sell magazines; not to provide an authoritative opinion.
I think this is the 2,214th time someone has posted that RRHOF clip when talking about Prince's guitar playing. It's the only clip anyone ever produces. I actually forgot to say in my original post "I wonder how long til someone posts the clip of Prince with Tom Petty".
As for Cobain, he's almost always in every top 10 list as the greatest of all time. He sucked, but when you kill yourself......TOP 10 in everything!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Cheerio
thats because Prince/his lawyers... delete just about EVERY other vid that pops up, so its about the only one thats always there LOL (and it is a great solo)
I had a friend who used to always go on and on about how great SRV was... and when ever he would put something on as an example of a great SRV track... it was ALWAYS a Hendrix cover... yeah, try convincing a Hendrix fan that someone does his song better? good luck with that pal.
Joined: Thu January 24, 2013 9:20 am Posts: 2687 Location: Great southern land.
MadTIGERmaN wrote:
I had a friend who used to always go on and on about how great SRV was... and when ever he would put something on as an example of a great SRV track... it was ALWAYS a Hendrix cover... yeah, try convincing a Hendrix fan that someone does his song better? good luck with that pal.
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
I think this is the 2,214th time someone has posted that RRHOF clip when talking about Prince's guitar playing. It's the only clip anyone ever produces. I actually forgot to say in my original post "I wonder how long til someone posts the clip of Prince with Tom Petty". 
